So my dad and I were just talking about the state of this nation, what with Zuma and Mbeki and the whole thing. I think there are several facts in play here that cannot be denied. For instance, the game has shifted from white vs. black to Zulu vs. Xhosa (maybe that’s what they’re referring to as “racism”?), no matter who the ANC brings up as a presidential candidate, they’re likely to be convicted criminals who have spent time at Robben Island, and despite the best assurances our government can give us, South Africa is indeed entering on to a slippery slope.
I was wondering - what if (serious “what if”) the Western Cape was to break away from South Africa and form a sovereign nation in it’s own right?
In other words, imagine if the Western Cape became its own country, with its own border posts (and perhaps currency), as well as a newly-formed government system elected by its residents (which’ll most likely put the DA in power). How would life look then?
For starters, the Western Cape has just about everything it needs in order to run a country:
- Infrastructure - roads and sewage and hospitals
- Administration - a high court, a working local administration
- Justice-related functions, like a high court and a prison
- Cosmopolitan capital - Cape Town is a one-of-a-kind African city in this regard
- Arable land - Mostly fruit production, plus wine, and the ability to shift to other kinds of farming
- Power generation - Koeberg, the old Cape Town station, and some other hydroelectric outfit near the coast
- Port - A really big one, right there in Cape Town
- Airport
- Train network
- Tourist attractions, entertainment, other amenities in that regard
- Industry - especially a growing online industry
- A unique culture
- … and a few other things I’m probably forgetting to list.
In short, it could realistically be done. Plus, there are a few other benefits:
- Forward-looking leadership
- Possible replacements for Telkom/Vodacom
- Freedom to focus on further developing our already world-class services
- Control over educational standards - bring UCT, etc back to their former recognition
- A tighter grip could be exercised on crime and corruption, without stall tactics from the ANC
- Reinstate bodies like the Scorpions on a local scale
- More money in less space = improved services and infrastructure for citizens
And then, of course, you have to wonder what will South Africa as a whole be losing? Mostly:
- Koeberg
- Taxpayer money
- Wine
- Tourist attractions
- People that know what they’re doing … lol
Between Bloemfontein, Durban and Pretoria, the rest of South Africa can and will continue to function as a stable(-ish) nation. It’s not like we’d be cutting out the heart of the country or something.
Ok, so the question, then - what does it take to form a new country?
In international law, the Montevideo Convention on the Right and Duties of States sets down the criteria for statehood in article 1: The state as a person of international law should possess the following qualifications:
(a) a permanent population;
(b) a defined territory;
(c) government; and
(d) capacity to enter into relations with the other states.
Yep, I think we have all of that available to us. From there, it’s more or less an extended process of saying “We hereby declare ___ a sovereign nation under the terms and whatever of the Montevideo Convention.”
Now wouldn’t that make an awesome Christmas present? What do you think - too desperate, or worth considering as a viable alternative to suffering under a corrupt national government?





I think you’ve lost it!!!!
LOL! That one just made my day :D
But seriously. Look at what “revolutionary” “democratic” governments have done to the rest of sub-Saharan Africa. Can you look at the numbers (not the perceptions) and honestly say that the road SA is currently on is going to get us anywhere good?
Don’t you think it’ll be a good idea to hold on to at least some sort of prosperity in this country? Inevitably, and given the current events, SA is going to fall into the same pits that the rest of Africa (aptly named “Darkest”) fell into.
I don’t want to leave. But I also don’t want to stay if that means I’m going to wake up one morning with a panga at my throat, or a “previously disadvantaged” individual occupying my job, or with the money in my bank account worthless, or with a police force that doesn’t give a shit about my wellbeing.
Yes, my proposal is incredibly drastic, but it’s not as if it’ll be the first time SA soil has been divided (a la Lesotho and Swaziland) - and it might just work to the benefit of those that actually care about tomorrow, and aren’t intent on seizing everything today.
I like it. A LOT. But lemme take the transfer to CPT first. ;)
I think it would be brilliant if something like this should ever happen.
Thanks Bergen and esvl for the positive (lol) comments :)
@Bergen - Why aren’t you in CPT already?! Sheesh … this is where all the action is, after all ;)
What makes you think the DA is forward thinking, they are politicians?…read scum of the earth.
What have they achieved?. I would be all for secession but dammed if i am going to live under a bunch of “liberal whiners” who are more impotent that a 80 year old man without a Viagra prescription
@gMk It’s not as if the DA’s ever had a chance, you know.
Hahahahaha…
An interesting scenario. But isn’t that what was abolished by joining the 4 provinces together all those years ago… Dare SA go back to that system? ;)
Oh… and you made one crucial error, you say, “People that know what they’re doing … lol” um… The cape doesn’t have that :P
@Robert we do! I know what I’m doing! Haha
I know it’s on the crazy side, but hey - it’s not as if borders are set in stone. Ask any Zimbabwean … lol